FALL 2005 #1

For indirect proof, suppose that G is a simple group of order 315 = (32)(5)(7). By the Sylow theorems, it follows that there are exactly 7 Sylow 3-subgroups of G. Letting P be a Sylow 3-subgroup, we have [G: NG(P)] = 7. So letting G act on the left cosets of NG(P) by left translation induces a permutation representation G --> S7 with kernel contained in NG(P). Simplicity of G forces this kernel to be the identity and hence we may assume that G < S7.

Let Q be a Sylow 5-subgroup of G. Note that Q is also a Sylow 5-subgroup of S7. So, since 52 does not divide 7!, it follows that

|NS7(Q)| = (7 - 5)!5(5 - 1) = 40.

Since Q < G < S7, we have NG(Q) < NS7(Q). So |NG(Q)| divides |NS7(Q)| = 40.

Now, the Sylow theorems imply that there are exactly 21 Sylow 5-subgroups of G. So

|NG(Q)| = |G|/21 = 315/21 = 15.

Since 15 does not divide 40, we have a contradiction.